Functional Neurological Disorder (FND) : a patient's guide
including Functional/Dissociative (non-epileptic) Seizures, Functional Movement Disorder and other functional symptoms
Functional Limb Weakness
Patients with functional leg weakness sometimes drag their leg behind them as shown in these two pictures
Hoover's sign is a positive sign of functional limb weakness.
This early medical film from 1902 shows a woman with functional weakness of the right leg being treated by the Romanian neurologist Marinescu.
Click on the picture to see the film which was published in the paper, "The origins of scientific cinematography and early medical applications" by
Alexandru C. Barboi, MD, Christopher G. Goetz, MD and Radu Musetoiu, MD. NEUROLOGY 2004;62:2082-2086
The film shows her walk before treatment and then three months later after treatment which largely involved hypnosis. It looks as if it was filmed on the same day but it wasn't!
The link is direct to the journal website
This factsheet was written in conjunction with
The video of Hoover's sign shows that Lucy has weakness of her right leg. When she tries to keep it flat on the floor she cant.
But when I ask her to lift up her normal left leg and focus on keeping that in the air then the weakness of the right leg temporarily goes away.
The explanation for this is that when Lucy is trying hard to move the right leg it doesnt do what its told, there is a problem in the function of the brain and nervous system getting in the way. But when she is focusing on the left leg, automatic movements return showing that the weakness is not due to damage.
You might need to watch the clip a few times to get your head round it!
•A dragging kind of walk - Patients with functional leg weakness sometimes have a very characteristic way of walking which means that their affected leg "drags" along the ground. This is different to someone with a stroke or multiple sclerosis who swings their leg if they are able to stand up.
What is functional limb weakness ?
Functional weakness is weakness of an arm or leg due to the nervous system not working properly. It is not caused by damage or disease of the nervous system.
Patients with functional weakness experience symptoms of limb weakness which can be disabling and frightening such as problems walking or a ‘heaviness’ down one side, dropping things or a feeling that a limb just doesn’t feel normal or ‘part of them’.
To the patient and the doctor it often looks as if you have had a stroke or have symptoms of multiple sclerosis. However, unlike these conditions, with functional weakness there is no permanent damage to the nervous system which means that it can get better or even go away completely.
How is a diagnosis of functional limb weakness made?
The diagnosis of functional weakness is usually made by a neurologist or stroke physician.
Patients with functional weakness have normal scans and other tests. When they are examined, the doctor usually finds a pattern of weakness typical of this problems and does not find changes in reflexes or other evidence of a structural neurological disease (like stroke).
This is because in functional weakness all the parts of the nervous system are there, they are just not working properly so that when you try to move your arm or leg it doesn’t do it as well as it should.
Your doctor may be able to find specific physical signs of functional weakness when you are examined and make the diagnosis in the same way as you would with a condition like migraine (which also does not have a ‘test’)
If you were a computer, it’s a bit a like having a software problem rather than a hardware problem
Other positive signs of functional weakness include the following, although none are 100% reliable and should not be used on their own:
•Collapsing weakness - this is a tendency for an arm or leg to 'collapse' when being tested. This may be interpreted by a doctor as 'not trying'. In fact, patients with functional weakness typically find that the limb gets weaker the more they try
•Hoover's sign - in this test, your affected leg may be weak when you try to push your foot down into the bed. However, when the doctor asks you to push up with your other leg the strength in your affected leg returns. Some patients with functional weakness use this sign as a form of physiotherapy to encourage normal movement in their affected leg (and to help demonstrate to themselves that the diagnosis is correct)
The video below shows me examining Lucy who had functional limb weakness affecting her right arm and leg. You can also see her talking about her facial spasm elsewhere on this website. Thank you Lucy for letting me share this video. You can also hear her talking about her symptoms on a BBC Radio 4 programme called 'Inside Health' in October 2012.
•A difference between the examination of power on the bed and when walking - some people with functional weakness have relatively normal examination of strength in the legs on the bed but weak legs when walking. The reverse can also be true. This is not because they are not trying to walk, the variability is a key feature of the diagnosis.
Normal scans and tests help to make the diagnosis, but the diagnosis is usually made at the bedside on the basis of these positive signs by a neurologist when they first meet you
How does functional limb weakness happen?
Functional limb weakness is a complex problem. It arises for different reasons in different people. Often the symptoms are accompanied by feelings of frustration, worry and low mood but these are not the cause of the problem.
We recognise a number of different situations in which functional weakness can arise. Your symptom may fall in to one of these categories although none of them may be relevant to you:
1. After an injury / with pain—People seem particularly vulnerable to functional weakness after a physical injury or if they have a lot of pain (particularly severe neck or back pain). Sometimes functional weakness overlaps with another condition called Complex Regional Pain Syndrome. Click on the link to find out more.
2. An illness with a lot of fatigue or bed rest— weakness can develop slowly in people who are suffering from a lot of fatigue or exhaustion. In some patients too much rest can bring the symptoms on. There may be an overlap in this situation with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. Click on the link to find out more.
3. Waking up from an anaesthetic after an operation or arising from sleep —this is not due to damage from the anaesthetic but may be something to do with the temporarily altered brain state when coming round. Similar things sometimes occur when you wake up normally.
4. After an episode of dissociation / panic attack- If your weakness came on suddenly it may have been associated with some other symptoms like lightheadedness and dissociation (a feeling that things around you were distant or disconnected). Dissociation is a bit like a trance and is described more in this website. Sometimes these episodes are very frightening, especially if they come 'out of the blue' and can lead to a panic attack. Once the panic attack is over it can leave behind the feeling that one half of the body is 'not right', perhaps heavy or tingly.
Sometimes symptoms come on after a dissociative seizure (click here)
5. No obvious precipitant - there may be no obvious precipitant, just as some people with migraine have them only when tired or stressed, whereas some have them for no reason at all.
Click on Treatment to find out more in general and find the specific page on the treatment of functional weakness